Midnight Ferry Menu
99 items in 17 sections · $0.75 – $17.00 · Ice Cream Shop in Newburgh, NY
Midnight Ferry’s menu lists 99 dishes and drinks, grouped into SIGNATURE, SOFT SERVE, HARD ICE CREAM, GELATO, SORBET, and CLASSIC TOPPINGS and more. Prices range from $0.75 to $17.00, and a typical item costs about $5.25. Popular choices include BOMBA, SOFT SAMMIE, PEANUT BUTTER PIE, PISTACHIO, and MANGO.
SIGNATURE 2
- BOMBA$9.75
Pistachio and Amarena Cherry Gelato, hot pressed in a fluffy Italian donut
- LA BOMBA$9.75
Your choice of two Ice Cream flavors hot pressed in a fluffy Italian donut
SOFT SERVE 1
- SOFT SAMMIE$5.00
Your choice schmushed between our homemade cookies
HARD ICE CREAM 14
- PEANUT BUTTER PIE$5.25
- COOKIE DOUGH$5.25
- SALTY CARAMEL$5.25
- CAMP FIRE 'SMORES$5.25
- COOKIES N CREAM$5.25
- CHOCOLATE$5.25
- VANILLA$5.25
- MINT CHIP$5.25
- STRAWBERRY$5.25
- CAPP. EXPLOSION$5.25
- CHURRO-CHATTA$5.25
- BUTTER PECAN$5.25
- BIRTHDAY CAKE$5.25
- COOKIE MONSTER$5.25
GELATO 5
- PISTACHIO$5.25
- HAZELNUT$5.25
- CINNAMON$5.25
- AMARENA CHERRY$5.25
- TIRAMISU$5.25
SORBET 2
- MANGO$5.25
- RASBERRY$5.25
CLASSIC TOPPINGS 9
- RAINBOW SPRINKLES$0.75
- CHOCOLATE SPRINKLES$0.75
- WHIPPED CREAM$0.75
- PEANUTS$0.75
- CARAMEL OR HOT FUDGE$0.75
- MARSHMALLOW SAUCE$0.75
- CHOCOLATE SAUCE$0.75
- PINEAPPLE CHUNKS$0.75
- FRUITY PEBBLES$0.75
ALL NATURAL & HOMEMADE TOPPINGS 9
- SLICED BANANAS
- STRAWBERRY SAUCE
- DARK CHOCOLATE SAUCE (VE)
- FRESH COOKIE DOUGH
- SWEET & SALTY WALNUTS
- PEANUT BUTTER SAUCE
- CARDAMOM CARAMEL SAUCE
- WARM BROWNIE
- MIXED BERRY CRUNCH
CANDY TOPPINGS 9
- GUMMY WORMS/BEARS$1.50
- MINI M&M'S$1.50
- CRUSHED OREO'S$1.50
- GRAHAM CRACKER CRUMBLE$1.50
- CHOCOLATE CHIPS$1.50
- CHOCOLATE CRUNCH$1.50
- NUTELLA$1.50
- PEANUT BUTTER CUPS$1.50
- TOASTED COCONUT FLAKES$1.50
SUNDAES 8
- MIDNIGHT FERRY CLASSIC$12.00
- STRAWBERRY FIELDS$12.00
- CHURRO PRETZEL SUNDAE$17.00
- WARM BROWNIE SUNDAE$14.00
- BANANA SPLIT$14.00
- DUBAI CHOCOLATE$16.00
- AFFOGATO$8.00
- CHOOSE YOUR OWN (2 TOPPINGS)$10.00
CRAFT SHAKES 8
- SNICKER SHAKE$12.50
- MIDNIGHT MOCHA$12.50
- CHOCOLATE EVERYTHING$12.50
- COOOOKIE MONSTA$12.50
- MINT CHIP OREO SHAKE$12.50
- CAMPFIRE S'MORE$12.50
- PB-NANA - BERRY$12.50
- PUMKIN GINGER SPICE$13.50
GRILLED CHEESE 3
- TRUFFLE GOUDA$15.00
SMOKED GOUDA, TRUFFLE CHEDDAR, HOT HONEY DRIZZLE
- SWEET TALLEGIO$15.00
TELLEGIO AND RASPBERRY JAM SPREAD, PICKLED RED ONION
- FRENCH ONION$15.00
GRUYERE CHEESE, CARAMELIZED ONION, TOPPED WITH HONEY DRIZZLE
SNACKS 6
- BIG PRETZEL$8.00
- TRUFFLE PRETZEL$8.00
- CHURRO PRETZEL$8.00
- PIZZA PRETZEL$12.00
- TOMATO SOUP$6.00
- CHICKPEA SALAD$9.00
CREPES 7
- HAM & CHEESE$15.00
- LEMON SUGAR$10.00
- RASPBERRY$12.00
- NUTTELA$12.00
- NUTTELA BANANA$14.00
- CINNAMON CRUCH$15.00
- DUBAI CHOCOLATE$16.00
HOT CHOCOLATE 4
- CLASSIC$8.00
- MAYAN$8.00
- PEPPERMINT$8.00
- BOOZY$16.00
COFFEE 6
- AMERICANO$3.50
- LATTE$5.00
- CHAI LATTE$5.50
- CAPPUCINO$5.00
- ESPRESSO$2.50
- IRISH$10.00
FLOATS 3
- ROOT BEER FLOATS$7.50
- SIGNATURE LAVENDER$8.50
- EGG CREAM$6.50
DRINKS 3
- ITALIAN SODA$4.50
BLOOD ORANGE, LIMONATA
- WATER / SELTZER$3.00
- LEMONADE$3.50
How these prices compare
Based on 26 menus with 914 priced items from ice cream shops in New York, the median menu item costs $5.00, and half of all items are priced between $3.15 and $9.50.
At Midnight Ferry the median listed price is $5.25, close to the typical $5.00 for ice cream shops in New York.
| Item | Here | Typical |
|---|---|---|
| Vanilla | $5.25 | $5.25 |
| Banana Split | $14.00 | $11.75 |
Typical prices are calculated from 26 menus in our guide.
Menu items and prices are provided for information and may have changed (last updated April 2026). Allergen information is not included – please ask the restaurant.